The Reload Bulletin Board
  Cast Bullet Cartridges
  How do my cast bullets look?

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
profile | register | preferences | abuse | faq | search

UBBFriend: Email this page to someone!  Convert to a Printer Friendly format.    Go to the previous topic in this forum.   Go to the next topic in this forum.
Author Topic:   How do my cast bullets look?
SMITH
Member
Member: 51 to 100 Posts

Posts: 74
From:
Registered: Mar 2003

posted 04-06-2003 08:19 PM    Click Here to See the Profile for SMITHClick here to email SMITHEdit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
I have cast about 1500 bullets so far and it is getting better. I am doing it with very minimal equipment, as in a BBQ grill, stainless bowl and a spoon. <img http://www.turbodieselregister.com/user_gallery/sizeimage.php?&photoid=4605&width=2

[Edited 1 time by SMITH on 04-06-2003 at 08:20 PM]

Sam
OLD FART
Honorary OLD FART

Posts: 5466
From: Alamogordo, New Mexico
Registered: Jan 2000

posted 04-06-2003 10:22 PM    Click Here to See the Profile for SamClick here to email SamEdit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
Smith,
I cannot really tell because the photo appears out of focus.
What to look for:
Is the base flat and square with a sharp corner?
Are the grooves clean and sharp cornered?

Sam

------------------
"Shoot lots, get good!"

pjh421
Senior Member
Senior Member: 101 to 300 Posts

Posts: 117
From: Davenport, IA, USA
Registered: Mar 2003

posted 04-06-2003 11:22 PM    Click Here to See the Profile for pjh421Click here to email pjh421Edit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
Looks like you've got some rounded driving bands and other evidence of either the mould being too cold or the casting alloy being too cold. Cast faster or, preferably, heat the mould on an electric side burner (incrementally) so its nice and toasty when that lead hits it. Be careful not to get your mould so hot that it warps! Your sprue plate will be the first to go. Crank up your alloy temp a bit more too. A pyrometer is quite useful for getting repeatable results. If your castings come out really smooth and shiny when using WW and range scrap, something's not hot enough. I'll take a little frostiness on the surface to get a properly filled out casting anytime and it doesn't hurt a thing. For plinking purposes using low powered loads and if the distance wasn't too great, I'd shoot your bullets. A pop can can't tell the difference.

Paul

SMITH
Member
Member: 51 to 100 Posts

Posts: 74
From:
Registered: Mar 2003

posted 04-07-2003 12:21 AM    Click Here to See the Profile for SMITHClick here to email SMITHEdit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
Must be the poor resolution I am required to use to post the pics, the bullets are sharp and filled out well, all features are sharp including the driving bands and the bases. They are as sharp as the features of the mold anyway. They come out at 160 grains on the shiny ones and 155 on the duller looking ones.

Paul, with the first alloy nothing I could do would make a bullet other than shiny and sharp, even soaking the mold in the molten metal for 10 minutes while I took a break while everything on high. Heat and mold temp made little difference, even slushy cold alloy made pretty shiny bullets that were only half filled out. The alloy from later today would not make a shiny bullet no matter what I did, I even did one cast with 20% tin (remelted into the alloy) and it was as dull as the rest. Frosty is a good description, but not frosty from heat, I know what heat frosting looks like from my first 2 attempts and this is not it.

Mold is an aluminum job, first cold bullet is essentially identical to #500 with everything is extremely hot. The tendency of bullets to stick to the mold a tad is the only difference heat seems to make.........

Gaelscot
Supreme Member
Supreme Member Over 751 Posts

Posts: 1185
From: Warrenton, VA
Registered: Jan 2003

posted 04-07-2003 05:39 PM    Click Here to See the Profile for GaelscotClick here to email GaelscotEdit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
Smith, I am by no means an expert on this, but a guy that I consider to be an expert gave me some sound advice about 25 years ago, and he had two glass bookcases full of medals and trophies to attest to the shooting consistency of his cast bullets. (1) Sometimes leaving your mold in the liquid metal doesn't quite get it hot enough - my acquaintance told me to keep a propane torch, securely anchored, turned on within easy reach, and if it looked like the bullets were coming out a little too cold, to warm the mold in the flame. It's not very scientific, but it works. This also assumes that your molten lead alloy is at a decent temperature. (2) The other piece of advice was to weigh the bullet (just as you have done). When they are a little too cool, they may solidify before gas bubbles have worked their way out, making them both a little lighter in weight and having a center of gravity somewhere other than the central axis of the bullet, leading to weird and unpredictable flight. I always tap my molds with a short wooden stick to help the gas escape before the lead solidifies, and if the any bullets come out even a grain or two lighter than the heaviest, they go back into the pot. Good luck. Gaelscot
pjh421
Senior Member
Senior Member: 101 to 300 Posts

Posts: 117
From: Davenport, IA, USA
Registered: Mar 2003

posted 04-07-2003 06:37 PM    Click Here to See the Profile for pjh421Click here to email pjh421Edit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
Gaelscot is right. I never used a propane torch on the mould blocks as I prefer an electric burner plate but there's no reason it wouldn't work. Your mould and alloy have to be HOT. The viscosity of your alloy is largely dependent upon temperature (and of course a little tin helps). It must flow like water into the corners and crevices of your mould cavity.

The mould blocks should have a heat relative to the alloy temp. That is to say that the two should work together. Your alloy must be hotter than your mould blocks (so the casting will solidify) but your mould blocks must be close enough temperature-wise to your alloy that the alloy does not cool too quickly as it contacts the mould blocks. Its a fine-tuned relationship.

Another thing you can do after you fiddle with the temperatures is to adjust your pouring height. This is best done with a bottom pour furnace. I wouldn't attempt this with a spoon or other similar dipper. It would make a pretty good mess. The greater the distance between the furnace spout and the mould, the greater velocity will your alloy have as it enters the mould. Getting the correct pouring height for a given alloy/heat combination can really make a difference. Often this will produce flow into the vent lines of the mould halves. That's when you know things are about as good as they can get with casting. The vent lines are so small that if lead is actually flowing into them, its a cinch that the corners of your mould cavity are filling in too.

I've never cast with a spoon, although I have used a Lyman dipper with excellent effect. Dippers are just too slow for me. I've got to get more bang for my buck, timewise.

Keep posting and between myself and the experts here, you'll get where you're going.

Paul

SMITH
Member
Member: 51 to 100 Posts

Posts: 74
From:
Registered: Mar 2003

posted 04-07-2003 07:01 PM    Click Here to See the Profile for SMITHClick here to email SMITHEdit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
Thanks for the advise guys. I will run the bext bactch a bit hotter and see what shakes out with that. I am casting about 400 per hour out of a 2 cavity aluminum mold, to be perfectly honest there is no way to go faster with my limited equipment so the temp is going to have to come up in the melt. My melt has not been quite watery, more like diesel fuel in viscosity. I had it watery on one of the first tries and it turned gold and blueish and crusty on top that required several fluxings to get back into the melt. I reduced the temperature and did not have that problem again. Bullets cast from that batch were identical to the shiny ones in the pics.

Tapping the mold will be added to the routine also, I am getting a +/- 1.5-2 grains or so in my bullets.

I appreciate the feedback, if there is anything else yuou think of please let me know.

pjh421
Senior Member
Senior Member: 101 to 300 Posts

Posts: 117
From: Davenport, IA, USA
Registered: Mar 2003

posted 04-07-2003 07:03 PM    Click Here to See the Profile for pjh421Click here to email pjh421Edit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
I should add that using more than 2% tin won't make a better casting, just a lighter, more expensive one.

I make big batches of alloy at one time, say 500 to 1000 pounds. That gives consistency over a longer period of time.

Also, (and I know I'm gonna hear about this) I have yet to crack the code on Lee moulds. I've tried several (.338, 9mm, 38, 45) and simply cannot get a casting equal to one from a good ductile iron block. Maybe its a mark of my inexperience.

My favorite moulds are those of Hensley & Gibbs. I believe Wayne has closed the doors some time ago but there are plenty of good used ones for sale. One of their best features is the THICK sprue cutter with an honest to goodness trough to keep the molten lead where it belongs: filling the cavities as the castings cool and shrink instead of spilling all over the place. The thicker sprue cutters don't warp as quickly as the thin ones like those on the Lee, Lyman, RCBS, etc. moulds. You can use a higher heat and, I believe, subsequently get better quality castings.

Once a sprue cutter warps, nothing short of a surface grind with shimming will give you flat bullet bases.

Paul

SMITH
Member
Member: 51 to 100 Posts

Posts: 74
From:
Registered: Mar 2003

posted 04-07-2003 09:26 PM    Click Here to See the Profile for SMITHClick here to email SMITHEdit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
Here are some better pics. http://www.turbodieselregister.com/user_gallery/sizeimage.php?&photoid=4634&width=2

http://www.turbodieselregister.com/user_gallery/displayimage.php?&photoid=4635&width=2

I have only added 2% tin as a rule, I have tried significantly more on a couple bullets and then melted them into the pot. I cannot see any difference in the bullet beyond 2%, they seem to be as good as they are going to get at 2% to my eye.

I am on the lookout for more molds, specifically a 200 grain 45 SWC, preferrably in the H&G 68 profile. They shoot great from my 45's. I do want to try an iron mold for sure. I am also going to attempt making some molds of my own this summer. I have access to the equipment........

Before I get too wound up over tons of detail I think I should try to shoot some of these and see what happens. I will borrow back the most accurate 357 I have ever seen (I sold it, I am a D.A. I know) and give them a run. The gun is capable of less than an inch and a half at 25 yards on a terrible day, if my loads will do 3" with me pulling the trigger I may just run off another 2-3000 and get some practice in.

MC1911
Supreme Member
Supreme Member Over 751 Posts

Posts: 4975
From: NC
Registered: Aug 2002

posted 04-08-2003 03:10 AM    Click Here to See the Profile for MC1911Click here to email MC1911Edit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
SMITH

Maybe I am just bias towards aluminum molds, but I have never had a bullet come out of a aluminum mold that would match in quality out of a steel mold.

What are you using for casting material; wheelweights, range scrap, etc? If you inadvertently got some bismuth in your melt that may be part of the problem. If that is the case than all you can do is scrap what you have in the pot and start over.

If your melt turned gold and bluish and crusty on top it is only because the heat is too high. Antimony and tin dissolves within the lead and fluxing serves only to remove dirt and other impurities from the alloy.

------------------
SAFE SHOOTING,

MC

ENNIS
Senior Member
Senior Member: 101 to 300 Posts

Posts: 145
From: l.burg, tn.usa
Registered: Dec 2001

posted 04-08-2003 07:15 AM    Click Here to See the Profile for ENNISClick here to email ENNISEdit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
SMITH
Try some more heat. Looks like they are a little to cool. You might want to increase the temp until the bullets take on a frosted appearance and then back off.
There is a learning curve in casting just as there is in anything else.
Also bear in mind that the proof is in the shooting. If what you have shoots good the rest don't mean a whole lot.
ENNIS
Tel
Junior Member
Junior Member: 6 to 50 Posts

Posts: 15
From: NSW Australia
Registered: Feb 2003

posted 04-10-2003 03:49 AM    Click Here to See the Profile for TelClick here to email TelEdit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
Yeah, those little wrinkles would indicate you need a bit more heat, but don't overdo it - you're almost there.

Al. moulds - absolutely love 'em. Been using Lee moulds for 30+ years now & I find 'em great. I also have a lot of CI & brass moulds in my 'stable' but the Lee give consistently better results & are much more comfortable to work with.

------------------
Tel

SMITH
Member
Member: 51 to 100 Posts

Posts: 74
From:
Registered: Mar 2003

posted 04-10-2003 09:43 AM    Click Here to See the Profile for SMITHClick here to email SMITHEdit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
Will do guys, thanks a ton!
pjh421
Senior Member
Senior Member: 101 to 300 Posts

Posts: 117
From: Davenport, IA, USA
Registered: Mar 2003

posted 04-10-2003 09:31 PM    Click Here to See the Profile for pjh421Click here to email pjh421Edit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
Tel,

Do your brass moulds have brass sprue cutters or are they made of steel? I never owned a brass mould. Do they cool more slowly than iron moulds?

Paul

BEAR
Older Than Dirt
Member
Older Than Dirt Member: 301 to 500 Posts

Posts: 339
From: Palisade, Co. USA
Registered: May 2000

posted 04-11-2003 03:40 AM    Click Here to See the Profile for BEARClick here to email BEAREdit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
Smith if you are using wheelweights another thing that might be you problem is zinc. some wheel weights contain zinc if the weight is silver colored and not tarnished like lead weights they contain zinc and that will give you fits. Bear
Tel
Junior Member
Junior Member: 6 to 50 Posts

Posts: 15
From: NSW Australia
Registered: Feb 2003

posted 04-11-2003 10:02 AM    Click Here to See the Profile for TelClick here to email TelEdit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
hi Paul, the brass moulds have a steel sprue cutter. I haven't noticed any real difference in cooling rates between these & the iron ones, but that might come down to my casting technique. In use the alloy 'freezes' at about the same rate.

------------------
Tel

pjh421
Senior Member
Senior Member: 101 to 300 Posts

Posts: 117
From: Davenport, IA, USA
Registered: Mar 2003

posted 04-11-2003 10:47 PM    Click Here to See the Profile for pjh421Click here to email pjh421Edit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
LBT moulds are aluminum and I have a high opinion of Veral Smith. Can anyone offer a comparison of the useability of his moulds as opposed to Lee moulds? I haven't used an LBT mould but his literature is intriguing. I understand the company was not producing moulds for a while. Is he still with us? Does anyone have information concerning Hensley & Gibbs company? I understand they haven't produced moulds for some time. I spoke with Wayne Gibbs last in 1995. He made me a 4 cavity #68 and it works like a dream. LBT has some cool designs too.

Paul

pjh421
Senior Member
Senior Member: 101 to 300 Posts

Posts: 117
From: Davenport, IA, USA
Registered: Mar 2003

posted 04-11-2003 11:23 PM    Click Here to See the Profile for pjh421Click here to email pjh421Edit/Delete MessageSearch the Cast Bullet Cartridges forumIP LoggedReply w/Quote
http://www.sixgunner.com/FAQ/lbt.htm

Hey! Look what I found. Whatever all this means, the guy really knows his stuff when it comes to bullet casting.

Paul

All times are ET (US)

Go to the previous topic in this forum.   Go to the next topic in this forum.

Administrative Options:
Back to Forums Main Page  Post New Topic  Post A Reply
Hop to:

Contact Us | TOS | The Reload Bench | Privacy Statement

© www.reloadbench.com 1999-2009 All Rights Reserved

Powered by Infopop www.infopop.com © 2000
Ultimate Bulletin Board 5.47e


Use these links to return to The Reload Bench main site...
Home | What's New | Search | Site Map | Guest Book | Links | Reload Components | Privacy Policy
Cartridges & Reload Data | Reload Info & Articles | Specifications | Survey | Contact | Link to Us | Sponsors